Abstract:
Objective This study aim was to develop a low-cost sensor capable of synchronous and high-precision monitoring soil moisture and salinity, and to systematically compare its performance with several domestic and international sensors, thereby to provide technical support for the optimization of Chinese-made sensors and their application in large-scale ecological monitoring.
Method Utilizing the standing wave ratio method, a sensor (SM926) capable of high-precision, real-time monitoring and transmission of soil water and salt content were developed by independently resolving the real and imaginary components of the complex dielectric constant, combined with a multi-parameter calibration approach. Its performance was systematically evaluated against other sensors.
Result The measurement accuracy of SM926 for soil volumetric water content (θv) and apparent electrical conductivity (σa) was better than 0.02 cm3 cm−3 and 0.3 dS m−1. Under indoor conditions, a comparative accuracy test involving three international sensors (CS655, TEROS 12, Hydra) and three domestic sensors (SMET-3, WHXPH, NH148) showed that SM926 performed optimally overall. Under indoor conditions of varying θv, σa, and temperature, comparisons between SM926 and the six other sensors revealed SM926 maintained stable and high accuracy (RMSE < 0.035 cm3 cm−3 and < 0.55 dS m−1), under varying θv (0.1 - 0.4 cm3 cm−3), salinity (0.6 - 4 dS m−1, low to medium levels), and temperature (0 to 40℃) conditions. Under the same conditions, the accuracy of SM926 was comparable to that of Hydra; its θv measurement accuracy was comparable to or slightly lower than that of TEROS 12 and CS655, but its σa measurement accuracy was higher than that of the latter two. Compared with WHXPH and SMET-3, SM926 exhibited better θv measurement accuracy and slightly lower temperature sensitivity in σa measurement. Moreover, SM926 outperformed NH148 in both θv and σa measurement accuracy. Under field conditions, the accuracy of SM926 was similar to that of Hydra and superior to that of WHXPH.
Conclusion SM926 provides a reliable solution for the stable monitoring of θv and σa dynamics under low to medium salinity. For deployment across large and heterogeneous areas, site-specific calibration is recommended to ensure sustained high accuracy.