密闭气室法测量碳通量误差分析

Error Analysis of Carbon Flux Measurement by the Closed Chamber

  • 摘要:
    目的 为量化自然环境因子对土壤CO2通量测量准确性的影响,明确风湍流和水分对介质内CO2运输的影响,进而分析密闭气室法在此背景下的潜在误差来源与偏倚程度。
    方法 实验使用了一款土壤碳通量标定仪,在两种风湍流条件下,使用3种不同孔隙度的石英砂作为参考介质,对密闭气室的测量性能进行研究。
    结果 在无风的情况下密闭气室测得的通量结果与标定仪的通量结果基本相等,而在湍流的情况下,密闭气室测量的通量结果被低估,细石英砂低估值在13% ~ 65%,中石英砂的低估值在22% ~ 68%。在风与水的交互作用下,低估程度又被加大,细石英砂的低估值在55% ~ 86%,中石英砂的通量低估值在72% ~ 89%。在无风的情况下密闭气室的测量结果比较准确,而在湍流的情况下,密闭气室测量的通量结果会被低估,并且在风和水的交互作用下这种低估现象更为显著。
    结论 为了确保密闭气室测量的通量结果更接近实际的碳通量情况,建议在无风的环境下进行测量,并尽量避免雨后直接测量。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective The aim was to quantify the impact of natural environmental factors on the accuracy of soil CO2 flux measurement, to clarify the effects of wind turbulence and moisture on CO2 transport in the medium, and analyze the potential sources of error and bias of the closed chamber method in this context.
    Method A soil carbon flux calibrator was used to investigate the measurement performance of the confined air chamber under two different wind turbulence conditions using three types of quartz sand with different porosities as reference media.
    Result It showed that the flux results measured by the confined air chamber in the absence of wind were essentially equal to those of the calibrator, whereas the flux results measured by the confined air chamber were underestimated under turbulent conditions, with underestimation ranging from 13%-65% for the fine quartz sand and 22%-68% for the medium quartz sand. The underestimation was increased again under wind-water interaction, with underestimations ranging from 55%-86% for fine quartz sand and 72%-89% for medium quartz sand flux underestimations. Measurements in the confined air chambers were more accurate in the absence of wind, whereas flux measured in the confined air chambers were underestimated in turbulent conditions, and this underestimation was even more pronounced under the interaction of wind and water.
    Conclusion The flux results measured in a closed chamber are closer to the actual carbon flux situation, it is recommended to measure in a windless environment and avoid direct measurement after rain as much as possible.

     

/

返回文章
返回